Antietam Under the Surface
I’m an avid reader of the My Year of Living Rangerously blog done by Ranger Mannie. Back in December, he posted Antietam Under the Surface and I began to think about the educational aspects of this post.
Here is a debate topic for your class: What can we learn by excavating a Civil War battlefield? There are those who would say that it is hallowed ground and should not be disturbed. Others say that we must learn from our past in order to preserve the future. I believe that what they did at Antietam was very interesting and will benefit generations to come. How does your class feel about it? Not too long ago, they found bones of a Civil War era soldier near the famous railroad cut at Gettysburg.
What about the actual excavation process? From the photos it appears that they used precision survey equipment and some type of computer software to map coordinates on a graph in order to see where the various items were recovered. Why is this important? It’s important because depending on the type of item found and what they know of the actual battle, they can make assumptions as to the unit that fought on that location or how heavy the fighting was in a particular area.
What about those bullets? I read somewhere that they estimate that three million bullets were fired during the Battle of Antietam. If a typical soldier could fire three rounds per minute, how long would it take a company of 100 or a regiment of 1,000 men to fire that many times?
Next time well talk more about weapons. Until then, read the other posts on Ranger Mannie’s blog and let him know what you think. You may also wish to explore Virtual Antietam and listen to their brief podcasts and search the monument database.
Jim,
Thanks for the nice comments.
Regarding using Youtube to teach history, you may wish to check out these movies that I posted to Youtube. Most of them deal with histroy in general or the Civil War in particular (others are just silly)
Best wishes, and keep in touch.
Mannie Gentile (Living Rangerously)
2006 Remberance Day Parade in Gettysburg
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5hMzG_jq2Gw
Mashuginet promo for Intellimate 3000 04:4
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xAfyRD9iutI
“Don’t Give Up the Ship” with Mannie Gentile (Part Two) 09:36
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=odHx5KKXLJQ
Don’t Give Up the Ship with Mannie Gentile (part one) 09:12
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l9GDuvRm-qM
Camping with Chuck and Mannie 09:25
Two middle-aged guys seek adventure in the wilds of the Michigan woods. Much hi
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UxfDObpWTiU
“Who Is That Guy?: the making of the Festival Poster” 09:58
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G28dyw_-VX8
Washington D.C.: Lincoln’s Fortress City 04:15
Excerpts of a 29 minute video still in production
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g6p-lcby-_U
Antietam 27th Virginia weekend 03:18
Living History reenactors share the lives of Confederate soldiers with visitors (more)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hco4WWfjVyA
Antietam Technology of War Weekend 2006 04:10
On August 12 and 13 Antietam National Battlefield hosted the Technology of War W
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rOOWOZEPlw0
Antietam Artillery Weekend 2006 05:05
Antietam National Battlefield’s annual event showcasing a four-gun battery being
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GbPN1fzy_iI
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5hMzG_jq2Gw
Gettysburg Rembrance Day 2006